Performance reviews are a corporate process where you receive professional feedback as an employee. All companies have this process to some extent, and the software industry is no exception. However, performance reviews get a bad reputation in tech due to negative stigma like burnout and PIP culture. It’s important to understand what the performance review process really means to you before taking it at face value.
What a Performance Review Looks Like
A manager or employee can relay to you feedback anytime, but the formal company-wide performance review typically happens once or twice a year. During this process, managers and/or close peers are asked to give feedback on your individual performance. Peer review is also known as a “360 review” because it includes peer opinions outside your direct manager’s.
Feedback takes the form of strengths and growth areas. For example, you may have strong execution and delivery skills of software projects, but you may be asked to focus more on leadership and teamwork values to better get along with others. The feedback may be actionable or general, and you may interpret it as you wish. After you receive your feedback, you may be eligible for compensation change, such as a bonus or base rate increase, depending on your performance.
One year, I received feedback that I was actually doing well and meeting expectations. I was delivering on important work, I contributed to team meetings where it mattered, and I was easy to work with. This was a signal that my performance and work ethic were acceptable; I just needed to maintain my level of business value. Unfortunately, despite positive feedback, I recently started the job and was ineligible for any compensation change.
The Meaning of Performance Reviews
Performance reviews are your leverage to drive career growth.
Performance reviews are intended to be a business mechanism to solve the business problem of talent development. The business looks for more ways to improve its employees, and they systematically deliver feedback through the review process to give you direction for professional growth. In turn, good performance reviews can land you promotions, higher compensation, eligibility for larger projects, and other career growing benefits.
Alongside the perks of good performance reviews, you can take advantage of feedback to push for professional development. To improve your peers, performance reviews are the intended place to leave professional feedback; for example, if you wish to see someone engage more in code reviews or design reviews, feedback is a good place to leave such criticism. Feedback you receive also becomes a data point for your personal growth. The best feedback I’ve received are all actionable: review code more slowly, own an operations related project, keep tickets updated and stakeholders informed, etc. Actionable feedback is easy to understand and gives you leverage with your manager to take action; in turn, this leads to promotion, career growth, and high performance marks.
When I started a job, my first year performance review feedback was that I had strong technical skills and was ready to own a project design. I candidly discussed this with my manager, and I used this feedback as leverage to push for owning a project. An opportunity came about when I could get involved with a cross-team infrastructure project which I took, and that really propelled my career because of how high visibility the project was. I was able to use the performance review process to actively grow my career prospects this way.
The Meaning of PIP
On the opposite side of performance reviews, some individuals may be placed on a Performance Improvement Plan or PIP. “Low performers” who fail performance reviews and aren’t delivering to business expectations would be placed on such a plan. The intention is to provide a path back to normal performance; the manager will prepare a several week plan with key milestones and expected deliverables you must fulfil, and passing all objectives completes the plan and takes you off of PIP. However, the consequence of failure is that you will be fired from the company.
Unfortunately, PIP often becomes a tech industry mechanism to forcefully exit employees from the company. Directly firing an employee carries risk because of discrimination and labor laws, so the PIP process creates the legal paper trail to prove an individual has failed to meet business expectations. This does not stop individuals from being selected for PIP: a manager that dislikes you may be more inclined to put you on PIP because they aren’t acting in your best interest. They will assign you PIP work that is practically impossible to achieve, with the intention of firing you in the first place.
Some tech companies, particularly the software industry giants, use PIP aggressively to raise the talent bar. Most famously, Amazon has the “unregretted attrition” process where a certain percentage of employees must be put on PIP each year. Microsoft has a similar metric called “good attrition” that measures employee departures that are a net benefit to the company. Meta has an “up or out” culture where you are expected to make E4 in 2 years and E5 in 5 years, or else you are forcefully exited from the company. These processes typically use PIP as the mechanism to force fire employees.
An aggressive PIP culture tends to create a lot of churn because employees cycle in and out frequently. This creates an unstable and toxic work environment where performance reviews become your most important objective rather than other business values. For example, some managers “hire to fire” to meet PIP quotas, preserving their core team at the expense of the unfortunate new hire. Others may discriminately select engineers for PIP as they see fit, and you have little control over this process.
I knew an individual that regularly got put on “focus” (at Amazon, the performance review stage prior to PIP) throughout 4 years of work. He was the unfortunate scapegoat that never got assigned great projects; most of his work involved operations, system development, or discussing with customers instead. He managed to escape twice by putting in the effort, but he eventually failed another round of focus and was put on PIP. By this point, he had already started job searching, and he found a more stable employer that offered a level promotion too.
In the software industry, PIP is rarely a reflection of your individual worth because companies take advantage of the process.
How to Use Performance Reviews
Performance reviews are a business game you must play and survive. Your experience may vary, and you may find yourself at the top of the performance interviews or perhaps at the very bottom. Once you accept the realities of the performance review system, you can start looking for professional opportunities to grow your career. Constructive feedback is a great starting point to improve upon, and these reviews allow you to have candid conversations with your manager regarding career growth. On the other hand, if you see yourself on the chopping block, it may be prudent to begin job searching before you inevitably get fired through the performance review process. They may be a good signal for your career direction, but performance reviews are never representative of your true individual worth as an engineer.